Front of Sour Punch Mystery Straws 4.5oz Tray
Sour Punch Mystery Straws 4.5oz Tray under a magnifying glass. Try and Guess the Flavor.
Sour Punch Mystery Straws mystery flavored candy in an evidence bag
Sour Punch Mystery Straws mystery flavored candy on a suspect board
Front of Sour Punch Mystery Straws 4.5oz Tray with raw mystery candy straws in front of pack
Back of Sour Punch Mystery Straws 4.5oz Tray
Front of Sour Punch Mystery Straws 4.5oz Tray
Sour Punch Mystery Straws 4.5oz Tray under a magnifying glass. Try and Guess the Flavor.
Sour Punch Mystery Straws mystery flavored candy in an evidence bag
Sour Punch Mystery Straws mystery flavored candy on a suspect board
Front of Sour Punch Mystery Straws 4.5oz Tray with raw mystery candy straws in front of pack
Back of Sour Punch Mystery Straws 4.5oz Tray

Sour Punch Fruity Mystery Straws, 4.5oz Tray

$1.89
Question Marks

Unwrap the Mystery.
The case starts here. Can you guess the flavor?

🕵️‍♂️ Case File: Sour Punch Mystery 

  • Status: Unsolved
  • Flavor: Classified
  • Mission: Crack the code
    — one sour straw at a time.
Manila folder with

🔍 Welcome to the Sweet & Sour Sleuth Society

Calling all candy detectives! There’s a top-secret flavor on the loose, and only one way to find it: taste it. Sour Punch Mystery Straws are the ultimate undercover candy — each one cloaked in black, dusted with signature sour sugar, and packed with a mind-bending mystery flavor your taste buds won’t see coming.

The Blind Taste Test Challenge

Your mission, should you choose to accept it: Take a bite. Analyze the flavor. Guess the answer. Do you trust your taste buds enough to solve the mystery on the first try? Or will it take a few “hmm, wait… is it—?” moments to uncover the truth?

Don’t worry — with approximately 4.5 servings per tray, there are plenty of clues to go around. Invite your fellow agents and launch your own flavor guessing game night.

Sour_Punch_Mystery_Caution_Tape.webp__PID:16351b32-052e-449a-a823-0bd7ee92107d

What We Know So Far

Sour_Punch_Mystery_Evidence_Punchie_Polaroid.webp__PID:144205c0-5c87-417e-ab8e-0503492bf070

Evidence #001: One Secret Flavor, Countless Theories

📍 Eyewitness sketch: A suspiciously smiley Punchie seen guarding the goods — flavor identity strictly classified.

Every Sour Punch Mystery Straw holds the same enigmatic flavor, but no one’s cracked the code yet. Could it be fruity? Tropical? Something you've tasted before — or something brand new?

The suspects are many. The clues are minimal. But the mission is clear: taste, guess, repeat. Your taste buds are the lead investigators here, and every chew gets you closer to solving the case.

Just don’t expect Punchie to spill the secret. That grin says nothing — but we have a feeling he knows everything.

Sour_Punch_Mystery_Evidence_Tray_Polaroid.webp__PID:671a5970-415d-40aa-a390-51384d8901fb

Evidence #002: The Wrapped Unknown

📍 Recovered from the evidence locker — one sealed pack of Sour Punch Mystery Straws. No flavor label. Highly suspicious.

At first glance, it looks like any other candy pack. But agents in the know can sense it: this one’s hiding something.

Tear it open and the investigation begins. A rush of tangy scent. A chew that’s satisfyingly bold. A flavor that dances just out of reach. This isn’t just sweet or sour — it’s unpredictable, shifting gears with every bite.

Think you’ve got the answer? Don’t be so sure. This flavor has a knack for dodging descriptions. You’ll need sharp instincts, sharper taste buds, and probably a second helping.

The mystery’s in the middle. The truth? Still classified.

Sour_Punch_Mystery_Evidence_Black_Straws_Polaroid.webp__PID:20144205-c05c-4781-beab-8e0503492bf0

Evidence #003: Electrifying Black Candy Straws

📍 Found at the scene: One handful of suspiciously dark straws, dusted in sour sugar and oozing intrigue.

They’re bold. They’re dark. They’re daring. These mysterious black candy straws look like they just stepped out of a secret agent film — and they're hiding a whole lot of flavor under that sour sugar disguise.

But don’t be fooled by the polished exterior. One bite in, and the texture reveals the truth: a perfectly chewy center that snaps back with just the right amount of resistance — a classic Sour Punch chew, made even more thrilling by the unknown.

This isn’t just candy. It’s a clue.
A coated conundrum, ready to be cracked.


ALLERGEN INFORMATION: CONTAINS WHEAT
CONTAINS BIOENGINEERED FOOD INGREDIENTS

Evidence #004: Nutritional Facts and Ingredients Label 

📍 Examined under magnifying glass: One standard-issue nutrition facts panel. No flavor listed. Just… “flavor.” Suspiciously vague.

Our agents poured over every inch of this label — calories, sugars, acids, even the fine print. Surely, somewhere, the secret flavor must’ve slipped through?

Nope.

Just the usual suspects: sugar, corn syrup, and one lone ingredient marked “artificial flavors.” That’s it. No name. No hint. Just more questions.

The facts might be there for health, but they’re no help for the case. If you’re hoping the ingredients will crack the code, think again — this one’s redacted.

The flavor remains at large.

Sour_Punch_Mystery_Evidence_Not_Bacon.webp__PID:60045932-dcab-46f1-a6f9-9ff89c8ff044

Evidence #005: The Bacon Alibi

📍 Interrogation notes: One Sour Punch Punchie Pig — suspiciously sweet, but ultimately innocent.

During the investigation, bacon was briefly considered a potential flavor suspect. But after a thorough grilling (figuratively, of course), Punchie Pig gave us the cold, hard facts: no pork involved.

In fact, this mystery is 100% bacon-free — and certified Kosher and Halal, too. So while Punchie Pig may look guilty, their record is squeaky clean.

Bacon’s been officially ruled out.
The mystery flavor? Still on the run.

Sour_Punch_Mystery_Caution_Tape2.webp__PID:8a6fcf03-1a1c-49d5-9002-4a404734e7b8

🧩 Plenty to Puzzle Over — For Everyone!

This case is open to all. Sour Punch Mystery Straws are Kosher and Halal certified, so every candy sleuth can join the investigation. Whether it’s a solo snack session or a full-blown family mystery party, there’s intrigue in every chew.

🗂️ File Your Findings... or Keep Guessing

Grab your tray. Gather your crew. Embrace your punch. The mystery is waiting…

Will you crack the flavor code? Or will this mystery keep your sweet tooth guessing? There’s only one way to find out.